Athletics vs. Yankees Prop Bets & AI Predictions (May 31, 2026)

Looking for expert MLB player prop predictions for May 31, 2026? Our AI breaks down the key data from the Athletics vs Yankees matchup so you can make smarter picks today.

In this MLB game, the Yankees are listed as the favorites with a -156 Moneyline, which gives them an implied 60.94% chance to win.

Athletics Preview:

These players have been hitting the ball well recently:

  • Lawrence Butler has gotten a hit in 1 of his last 10 games (hit his line in 10% of 10 games)
  • Brent Rooker has gotten a hit in 0 of his last 10 games (hit his line in 0% of 10 games)
  • Carlos Cortes has gotten a hit in 0 of his last 10 games (hit his line in 0% of 10 games)

The player with the highest projected chance at a Home Run is:

  • Shea Langeliers has a 0.25 Home Run projection

Yankees Preview:

These players have been hitting the ball well recently:

  • Aaron Judge has gotten a hit in 0 of his last 10 games (hit his line in 0% of 10 games)
  • Anthony Volpe has gotten a hit in 0 of his last 10 games (hit his line in 0% of 10 games)
  • Austin Wells has gotten a hit in 0 of his last 10 games (hit his line in 0% of 10 games)

The player with the highest projected chance at a Home Run is:

  • Aaron Judge has a 0.26 Home Run projection

Roster Outlook

Athletics Yankees
Projected Pitcher Projected Pitcher
Jacob Lopez Will Warren
Projected Roster Projected Roster
  • Carlos Cortes (RF)
  • Nick Kurtz (1B)
  • Shea Langeliers (C)
  • Brent Rooker (DH)
  • Tyler Soderstrom (LF)
  • Henry Bolte (CF)
  • Jeff McNeil (2B)
  • Zack Gelof (3B)
  • Darell Hernaiz (SS)
  • Paul Goldschmidt (1B)
  • Ben Rice (DH)
  • Aaron Judge (RF)
  • Cody Bellinger (CF)
  • Amed Rosario (3B)
  • Jazz Chisholm (2B)
  • Anthony Volpe (SS)
  • Jose Caballero (LF)
  • Austin Wells (C)

Athletics

Projected Pitcher
Jacob Lopez
Projected Roster
  • Carlos Cortes (RF)
  • Nick Kurtz (1B)
  • Shea Langeliers (C)
  • Brent Rooker (DH)
  • Tyler Soderstrom (LF)
  • Henry Bolte (CF)
  • Jeff McNeil (2B)
  • Zack Gelof (3B)
  • Darell Hernaiz (SS)

Yankees

Projected Pitcher
Will Warren
Projected Roster
  • Paul Goldschmidt (1B)
  • Ben Rice (DH)
  • Aaron Judge (RF)
  • Cody Bellinger (CF)
  • Amed Rosario (3B)
  • Jazz Chisholm (2B)
  • Anthony Volpe (SS)
  • Jose Caballero (LF)
  • Austin Wells (C)

Recent Form

Athletics

Last 5 Games (1-4)

Date Opponent Result Score
May 30 vs NYY W 6-4
May 29 vs NYY L 2-8
May 27 vs SEA L 1-9
May 26 vs SEA L 1-4
May 25 vs SEA L 2-9

Yankees

Last 5 Games (4-1)

Date Opponent Result Score
May 30 vs ATH L 4-6
May 29 vs ATH W 8-2
May 27 vs KC W 7-0
May 26 vs KC W 15-1
May 25 vs KC W 4-3

Explore more MLB player prop predictions with PlayerProps.ai, or use our Prop Predictor tool to find today’s top edge picks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best player prop bets for Athletics vs Yankees?

  • Our AI models are analyzing the latest data for this MLB matchup. For the most current player prop recommendations, check our Prop Predictor tool.

What time does Athletics vs Yankees start?

The game is scheduled for 5/31/2026, 4:05:00 PM.

Ready to Elevate Your Betting? Explore Our Tools!

Want to take your handicapping to the next level? We’ve built a suite of powerful tools designed to give you an edge. Whether you’re looking for deeper insights or smarter strategies, our resources are here to help you make more informed decisions:

  • Prop Predictor tool – Forecast individual player and game prop outcomes with data-driven projections.
  • Optimizer tool – Craft optimal betting strategies and maximize potential returns across various markets.
  • Moneyline tool – Analyze outright winner probabilities and find value in moneyline wagers.
  • Spread tool – Gain an edge on point spread bets with detailed performance analytics.
  • Total tool – Project over/under outcomes with historical data and expert insights for game totals.
  • Betting Trends tool – Uncover key patterns and public wagering habits to inform your picks.
  • Team Trends tool – Dive deep into team-specific performance metrics and historical data.
  • Odds Comparison tool – Instantly compare odds from top sportsbooks to ensure you get the best value.
  • Props Comparison tool – Find the most favorable odds on player and game props across different books.
  • NRFI tool – Specialized insights and predictions for “No Runs First Inning” bets.

More MLB May 31 Games

Looking for more MLB action? Check out our full MLB prop bets archive for every game, every day.

Popular articles

Get the latest AI-powered prop bet predictions and matchup insights for the WNBA game of Wings vs Storm on Jun 1. Find edges before you place your bet.
Get the latest AI-powered prop bet predictions and matchup insights for the MLB game of Athletics vs Yankees on May 31. Find edges before you place your bet.
Get the latest AI-powered prop bet predictions and matchup insights for the MLB game of D-backs vs Mariners on May 31. Find edges before you place your bet.
Get the latest AI-powered prop bet predictions and matchup insights for the NBA game of Knicks vs Spurs on Jun 3. Find edges before you place your bet.
Get the latest AI-powered prop bet predictions and matchup insights for the WNBA game of Lynx vs Mercury on Jun 1. Find edges before you place your bet.
Get the latest AI-powered prop bet predictions and matchup insights for the MLB game of Rockies vs Giants on May 31. Find edges before you place your bet.